The final cut

Here's the complete list of 88 hymns carols I ended up with:

TITLE
A child this day is born
A stable lamp is lighted
Ah, bleak and chill
With wondering awe
All poor men and humble
Unto us is born a son
Angels from the realms of glory
As with gladness
Angels we have heard on high
Shepherds in our fields abiding
When the crimson sun had set
Bring your torches
Auld lang syne
A Christmas Auld Lang Syne
One Candle Is Lit
Away in a manger
Boar’s head carol
Chestnuts roasting on an open fire
Cherry Tree Carol
As Joseph was a-walking
As Joseph lay uneasy
Christmas cometh caroling
Come and sing the Christmas story
Deck the halls
Deck us all with Boston Charlie
All ye mountains
Come, thou long-expected Jesus
Emmanuel
Ding dong! Merrily on high
Gesù Bambino
Glad music fills the Christmas sky
Go, tell it on the mountain
God rest ye merry, gentlemen
How great our joy
The old year now away is fled
What child is this?
A child is born on Christmas morn
Arise, the Kingdom is at hand
Hail to the Lord’s Anointed
Hark! the herald angels sing
Beecham’s Pills
Here We Come A-Wassailing
God is born, great powers tremble
I heard the bells on Christmas day
I saw three ships come sailing in
A ship there comes, a-laden
In Bethlem town
Love Came Down at Christmas
Quoth the fir tree
Good King Wenceslas
Gentle Mary laid her child
Spring hath now unwrapped her flowers
A Visit from St. Nicholas
A Visit from Whitebeard
White Christmas
Some children see him
There's a song in the air
Maria wandered through a wood
Lutefisk, O Lutefisk
O Christmas tree
Twelve days of Christmas
Ho sankta nokto!
O holy night!
Rock of Ages (Maoz Tzur)
Raise up your voices
Silent night
Silver bells
The holly and the ivy
Lo, how a rose e'er blooming
Now bless the God of Israel
O little town of Bethlehem
O come, O come, Emmanuel
Magnificat (My heart sings out)
The first Nowell
Joy to the world
Jesus, the light of the world
’Twas in the moon of wintertime
Good Christian men, rejoice
In dulci jubilo
Orientis partibus (Song of the Ass)
Jesus, our brother, kind and good
Adeste fideles
O come, all ye faithful
For ages women hoped and prayed
It came upon the midnight clear
In Heaven, there grows a linden tree
We three kings